The Toby Carvery desserts menu, badged Toby Pudding Co on most menus, covers six classic puddings, a range of sundaes and one dessert served inside a Yorkshire pudding. Sundaes started from £2.79 on the official menu we checked in August, and a restaurant menu we reviewed in October listed desserts from £3.89.
This guide covers every dessert, the sundae range and toppings, the Yorkshire pudding dessert, kids’ options, dietary notes and how desserts fit with the set menu.
The Classic Toby Carvery Puddings
Six classic puddings sit at the centre of the menu. Each is served with a choice of cream, ice cream or custard, and a vegan custard option is available.
| Classic pudding | What it is |
|---|---|
| Sticky Toffee Pudding | Home-baked and drizzled with toffee sauce, served warm |
| Baked Vanilla Cheesecake | New York-style, served with fluffy cream |
| Chocolate Fudge Cake | Rich and dense, served with your choice of topping |
| Cookie Dough Chocolate Brownie | With salted caramel sauce, fresh strawberries and fluffy cream |
| American-Style Pancakes V | With Cadbury Flake, chocolate sauce, crispy chocolate pieces, ice cream and cream |
| Rice Pudding | A creamy rice pudding topped with strawberry jam |
No prices for the classics: individual pudding prices vary by restaurant and are not published nationally, so we do not quote a figure that may not match yours. The cheesecake price is in the price section below.
Toby Carvery Sundaes and Toppings
The sundae range is the cheapest way to add a dessert, and the official menu lists sundaes from £2.79. You can add toppings for 40p to 50p each.
| Sundae | Price (official menu, Aug 2026) |
|---|---|
| Dairy Ice Cream Sundae | £2.79 |
| Chocolate Brownie Ice Cream Sensation | £3.69 |
| Honeycomb Dream Sundae | £3.79 |
| Lemon Cheesecake Sundae (new) | £3.89 |
| White Bubble Sundae (menu reviewed Oct 2026) | £3.89 |
| Add a topping | Price (Aug 2026) |
|---|---|
| Toffee pieces | 40p |
| Chocolate flake | 40p |
| Marshmallows | 50p |
| Chocolate sprinkles | 50p |
| Popping candy | 50p |
Sundae ranges change, so the White Bubble Sundae from the October menu and the four from the August official menu may not all be at your restaurant. Ask what is available.
A Dessert Served Inside a Yorkshire Pudding
This is the item that surprises people most. Instead of a Yorkshire pudding next to a roast, Toby Carvery serves one filled with dessert, and there is a sharer version too.
Yorkshire Pudding Apple Strudel
A warm Yorkshire pudding filled with dairy ice cream, salted caramel, mini fudge pieces and Bramley apple sauce.
Yorkie Puds Pud Sharer
Several mini Yorkshire puddings loaded with dessert toppings, built for the table to share.
Availability
Check the app. Menus change by restaurant and over time, and prices are not quoted here.
Toby Carvery Dessert Prices
A menu we reviewed in October 2026 listed desserts from £3.89. The official pudding menu we checked in August 2026 listed sundaes from £2.79 and a baked vanilla cheesecake at £5.29.
| Dessert | Official menu, Aug 2026 | Menu reviewed, Oct 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Sundaes | from £2.79 | White Bubble Sundae £3.89 |
| Cheesecake | Baked Vanilla Cheesecake £5.29 | from £4.29 |
| Dessert as a set menu third course | Not listed | Included in the 3-course set menu from £15.29 |
Why two sets of prices? They come from two sources checked at different times, and restaurants can price differently. Confirm the price for your own restaurant in the Toby Carvery app. See the Toby Carvery prices guide for starters, mains and drinks, and the price calculator to add dessert to a bill.
Vegan, Vegetarian and Gluten-Free Toby Carvery Desserts
Most classic puddings contain dairy, a vegan custard option is available, and sauce and topping choices can change whether a dessert is suitable for a vegan or gluten-free diet.
Vegetarian
The American-style pancakes are vegetarian, and most puddings are vegetarian. Confirm for your restaurant.
Vegan
A vegan custard is offered. Ask staff about the dessert and sauce rather than assuming, because combinations differ.
Gluten-free
Some desserts may suit a gluten-free diet, but shared kitchens mean cross-contamination is possible. Confirm with staff and the allergen app.
Allergens and calories
Use the in-app allergen filter and our allergen guide, gluten-free guide and nutrition guide.
Toby Carvery Kids’ Desserts
Children get their own Make Your Own Sundae: ice cream with a choice of toppings and sauce, part of the kids’ two-course meal.
See the kids’ menu guide for the full children’s menu, age bands and family bill examples.
Dessert With Your Meal: Set Menu and Hot Drink Pairings
Weekday set menu
The three-course set menu includes a dessert as the third course, from £15.29 at the restaurant we reviewed, with an extra course at +£2.00. It runs Monday to Friday.
Dessert on its own
Desserts are ordered through table service, separate from the carvery deck, so you can visit just for pudding and a drink.
With a hot drink
Some restaurants offer a pairing that adds a mini chocolate brownie or a mini lemon blizzard sundae to tea or coffee.
Set menus, including their dessert course, are excluded from the main discounts. See the offers guide and the Carvery Club guide, and read about the main course in the Sunday roast guide and the drinks menu.
How this guide was put together. Dessert descriptions, sundaes, toppings and the Yorkshire pudding desserts come from Toby Carvery’s official pudding menu, checked in August 2026. Prices come from that menu and from a restaurant menu we reviewed in October 2026, each labelled with the month. We do not run the restaurants or set prices.
Last reviewed October 2026. Always confirm the menu and prices with your restaurant or the app. Related guides: Toby Carvery menu, prices, Toby Tasters and kids’ menu.
Toby Carvery Desserts FAQs
Practical questions people ask before ordering pudding.
1What desserts does Toby Carvery have?
The dessert menu, badged Toby Pudding Co on most menus, includes classic puddings such as sticky toffee pudding, baked vanilla cheesecake, chocolate fudge cake, cookie dough chocolate brownie, American-style pancakes and rice pudding, a range of sundaes, and a dessert served inside a Yorkshire pudding.
2How much are Toby Carvery desserts?
A menu we reviewed in October 2026 listed desserts from £3.89, with a White Bubble Sundae at £3.89 and cheesecake from £4.29. The official pudding menu we checked in August 2026 listed sundaes from £2.79 and a baked vanilla cheesecake at £5.29. Prices vary by restaurant, so check the app. See the Toby Carvery prices guide.
3What sundaes are on the Toby Carvery menu?
The official menu listed a Dairy Ice Cream Sundae, a Chocolate Brownie Ice Cream Sensation, a Honeycomb Dream Sundae and a Lemon Cheesecake Sundae in August 2026, and a menu we reviewed in October listed a White Bubble Sundae. Sundae ranges change, so check what your restaurant has.
4Can I add toppings to a Toby Carvery sundae?
Yes. The official menu listed toppings at 40p for toffee pieces and chocolate flake, and 50p for marshmallows, chocolate sprinkles and popping candy, as checked in August 2026.
5What is the Yorkshire pudding dessert at Toby Carvery?
It is a dessert served inside a Yorkshire pudding. The Yorkshire Pudding Apple Strudel is a warm Yorkshire pudding filled with dairy ice cream, salted caramel, mini fudge pieces and Bramley apple sauce, and the Yorkie Puds Pud Sharer is a plate of mini Yorkshire puddings with dessert toppings to share.
6Are there vegan desserts at Toby Carvery?
Most classic puddings contain dairy, though a vegan custard option is available. Because sauce and topping combinations differ by restaurant, ask staff or use the allergen app and our allergen guide rather than assuming a dessert is vegan. See the vegan and vegetarian guide.
7Are there gluten-free desserts at Toby Carvery?
Some desserts may be suitable, but cross-contamination is possible in a shared kitchen, so confirm with staff and the allergen app. See our gluten-free guide.
8Is dessert included in the set menu?
The weekday set menu has three-course options that include a dessert as the third course, from £15.29 at the restaurant we reviewed, and an extra course adds £2.00. Set menus run Monday to Friday and availability varies. See the prices guide.
9Can I order dessert without a main course?
Yes. Desserts are ordered through table service separately from the carvery deck, so you can visit for a pudding and a drink.
10Can I add a mini dessert to tea or coffee?
Some restaurants offer a hot drink pairing that adds a mini chocolate brownie or a mini lemon blizzard sundae to a tea or coffee, a smaller alternative to a full pudding. Ask staff what is available.
11What desserts do kids get?
Children can have a Make Your Own Sundae, ice cream with a choice of toppings and sauce, which is part of the kids’ two-course meal. See the kids’ menu.
12Where can I find calories for desserts?
Calorie information is available at the carvery deck and through the allergen app, alongside the standard adult guidance of around 2,000 kcal a day. See our nutrition and calories guide.
Menus and prices vary by restaurant and change over time. This independent guide is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by Toby Carvery or Mitchells & Butlers.
